GOD, MAN and CHARLES DARWIN
I was very unwilling to give up my belief…. Thus disbelief crept over me at a very slow rate, but was at last complete. —Charles Darwin
- * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
I have on occasion speculated that if I weren’t a deist, I would without doubt (or more accurately, with doubt) be an agnostic. For me, atheism is a non-starter; I cannot rule outΒ possibilitiesΒ beyond the pointΒ whereΒ mere mortals haveΒ the capabilityΒ to ascertain.Β For me, the difference between anΒ atheist and an agnostic is humility: we’reΒ limited humans.Β Even if you and I don’t believe in the ‘revealed’ God, why fall into the trap of conflating man’s invented God (religion) with theΒ fact of creation and thus the plausibility of a creator, divorced andΒ absent though He (It) may be from what He (It)Β hath wrought?
These thoughts were in the back (but not too far back) of my mind as I was reading CHARLES DARWIN – A SCIENTIFIC BIOGRAPHY by the late Sir Gavin de Beer, a British scientist and author of many books on zoology, embryology, genetics, etc. I’d come upon this old book while library-browsing, and realized that, while we all know what Darwin was famous for, do we really know Charles Darwin, the man? What was he like, and what did he believe at various points in his life as his thinking evolved (pun intended)?
Perhaps the most important thing to keep in mind in getting to know Darwin is that he was “The man who struggled with his own ideas” (BBC website), keeping silent for 20 years before going public with his painstaking research, and describing hisΒ writing On the Origin of Species as “like confessing a murder.” Its publication in 1859 represents “one man’s struggle with the most radical idea of all time — the idea that humans shared a common ancestor with apes.”
Darwin was born of Christian parentsΒ in 1809 at Shrewsbury, England, the son of a successful physician and a mother who died when Charles was eight years old, after which (quoting de Beer) “his home upbringing devolved largely on his elder sisters to whom, in spite of their persistent fault-finding, he was ever grateful for instilling in him the spirit of humanity.” Additionally, his grandfathers were important Enlightenment figures: Josiah Wedgewood, anti-slavery campaigner, and Erasmus Darwin, a doctor who ‘wrote the book’ (ZOONOMIA) on the radical idea that one species could transmute into another.
Darwin’s father wished him to become a doctor, but after realizing that his son had an aversion to practicing medicine, he (quoting de Beer) “proposed that he [Charles] take holy orders in the Church of England. Indeed, at this time in his life, he felt so convinced of the truth of his religion” that he accepted. But after three years of studies at Christ’s College, he considered the time “wasted. His greatest pleasure was collecting beetles for the sheer joy of collecting.” After meeting men of distinction in botany and other fields, he studied geology and read books “fromΒ which he derived a zeal to travel and study natural history.”
AΒ set of fortuitous happenings led to a position as a neophyte naturalist on the HMS Beagle, which set sail from England in Dec. 1831, not to return until October 1836….five years of meticulous observations, collecting specimens andΒ exhaustive exploration too lengthy to detail here, but whichΒ began a new chapter in the history of science.
Years later, “The result of his experiences was thatΒ (says de Beer quoting Darwin) My theology is a simple muddle; I cannot look at the universe as the result of blind chance, yet I can see no evidence of beneficent design, or indeed of design of any kind, in the details….the impossibility of conceiving that this grand and wonderful universe, with our conscious selves, arose through chance, seems to me the chief argument for the existence of God; but whether this is an argument of real value, I have never been able to decide. I am aware that if we admit a first cause, the mind still craves to know from whence it came. Nor can I overlook the difficulty from the immense amount of suffering through the world. The safest conclusion seems to me that the whole subject is beyond the scope of man’s intellect.”
“Darwin never felt any but the most friendly and charitable feelings for those who differed from him in matters of religion, provided that they were honest. This is amply confirmed from both sides. Rev. J. Brodie Innis wrote to Darwin, We often differed, but you are one of those rare mortals from whom one can differ and yet feel no shade of animosity, and that is a thing of which I should feel very proud if anyone could say it of me. Darwin’s description of their relations was equally generous: Innis and I have been fast friends for thirty years, and we never thoroughly agreed on any subject but once, and then we stared hard at each other, and thought one of us must be very ill.”
And now I feel I know Charles Darwin, the man.
P.S. My thanks to Richard Cahill, whose July 23rd post “God, Man and Donald Trump”Β inadvertently suggested my title for this post after I thought better of my original (or more accurately, less original)Β title.
DoesItEvenMatterWhoIAm? 5:02 pm on July 24, 2015 Permalink |
Very cool! I like this post as both an Anthropologist and an Agnostic! Very well written! β‘ Melanie
LikeLiked by 1 person
MΓ©l@nie 10:06 am on July 27, 2015 Permalink |
excellent, indeed, so same here, Melanie… π btw, I’m MΓ©lanie from Toulouse, France… π
LikeLiked by 2 people
DoesItEvenMatterWhoIAm? 10:07 am on July 27, 2015 Permalink
Hi! How fun to say hello around the world to another Melanie!!!!
LikeLike
DoesItEvenMatterWhoIAm? 10:08 am on July 27, 2015 Permalink
Oh by the way I am in Salem, Oregon, USA
LikeLike
mistermuse 6:24 pm on July 24, 2015 Permalink |
Thanks! You are the (even better) female equivalent of a gentleman and a scholar π
LikeLiked by 1 person
DoesItEvenMatterWhoIAm? 6:50 pm on July 24, 2015 Permalink |
Awww thanks π
LikeLiked by 1 person
BroadBlogs 6:26 pm on July 24, 2015 Permalink |
I’m basically an agnostic but choose to err on the side of belief in a higher power simply because I feel more empowered when I do, And the world seems more magical.
LikeLiked by 2 people
mistermuse 7:40 pm on July 24, 2015 Permalink |
I’m not so sure that we fall on different sides of the deist/agnostic comparison – your belief in “a higher power” sounds similar to me being an agnostic if I weren’t a deist. Perhaps it somewhat depends on one’s definition of deist. As I understand it, no deist believes in a revealed God, but some may believe in the efficacy of prayer and/or even an afterlife. Personally, I believe prayers are useless and a possible afterlife is “beyond the scope of man’s intellect” (to quote Darwin).
LikeLike
Don Frankel 4:54 am on July 25, 2015 Permalink |
Who else can I have these conversations with? We’ve been on this subject on and off for the last few years. I’ve realized something about you and Richard and other people I know, their religious upbringing seems to almost have been traumatic. In that, someone or someones tried to brow beat all of you into believing. I was brow beaten into non-believing. Makes me wonder why people get so excited about it all. Or should I use the term stimulated? Mental illness ran rampant in my family.
What most people don’t want to realize is we just can’t know. We are stuck with these pathetic little things we call minds. We can’t see or hear things that are happening around us all the time. We can perceive just so much and understand it seems, less.
Darwin is a prime example of how we are at our best when asking questions and at our worst when we assume we know all about something, we can’t possibly know.
LikeLike
mistermuse 6:53 am on July 25, 2015 Permalink |
Don, your upbringing strikes me as a prime example of that old saying to the effect that what doesn’t kill you only makes you stronger. Perhaps I am another example, though under different circumstances (my parents divorced when I was 12 and from that point I grew up without a father; looking back, I see that as the beginning of a traumatic period, though I didn’t understand it at the time). Anyway, I’m glad to have gotten to ‘know’ Darwin, because I didn’t realize the anguish he went through in evolving into the man he became – a man I can thoroughly empathize with and relate to.
LikeLike
arekhill1 10:33 am on July 25, 2015 Permalink |
While I appreciate anybody paying attention to me, if there is an afterlife, Darwin must be fuming in it for being mentioned in the same breath as Trump, Sr. Muse.
LikeLike
mistermuse 12:21 pm on July 25, 2015 Permalink |
No doubt that’s true, Ricardo….plus, the fact that The Donald represents a major step backward on the evolutionary ladder would seem to raise questions about The Theory. Darwin can’t be too happy about that, either.
LikeLiked by 1 person
scifihammy 11:35 pm on July 25, 2015 Permalink |
I never saw this post in my Reader – some posts have been appearing lower down among ones I have already read.
I’m glad I came to have a look at your Blog and find this very interesting essay on Darwin. I think it is hard nowadays to imagine just how difficult it was for Darwin to accept his own theory and present it to a narrow-minded world. I got his Origin of the Species out of the library once. It is a massive work, both literally and figuratively.
LikeLiked by 1 person
mistermuse 6:32 am on July 26, 2015 Permalink |
That’s an excellent point about Darwin….and it seems that “narrow-minded world” will ever be with us. In the past 100 years, we’ve seen everything from the Scopes Monkey Trial to the present violence and barbarity of religious fundamentalism. Not much evolution in that world.
LikeLike
M. Talmage Moorehead 10:49 pm on August 16, 2015 Permalink |
“For me, the difference between an atheist and an agnostic is humility…”
That’s brilliant! I love it. Thank you.
Talmage
LikeLiked by 1 person
mistermuse 5:58 am on August 17, 2015 Permalink |
I “humbly” (working on the more realistic “semi-humbly,” but evolution is a slow process) accept your judgment. Thanks for reading and commenting.
LikeLike